Advising pension scheme sponsors

Balancing the requirement for pension funding with the need for sustainable sponsor growth.


Our client, the leader in wastewater treatments, needs to continually invest in order to remain competitive.

While they fully accept and appreciate their long term commitment to funding their legacy Defined Benefit pension scheme, they need to balance this against their need to invest in the business, for example in technologies, product and expansion overseas.

The last actuarial valuation of the scheme had left it with escalating recovery plan contributions, already standing at almost 7% of annual turnover. These were a barrier to its growth plans. It felt that there was insufficient balance in the risks taken by the business and the pension scheme.

How we helped

We helped our client prepare a business case for the trustees for a reduction in recovery plan contributions, demonstrating the positive impact of the business plan on the employer covenant and the long term security of members’ benefits.

We identified the likely impact on the funding position of recent favourable scheme experience, taking onto into account market and interest rate movements and drew this to the sponsor’s attention.

With our help, our client also negotiated on the degree of prudence used by the trustees at the earlier
valuation. The trustees were able to support a reduction in prudence in the valuation of the liabilities in some areas.

A combination of recent favourable experience and a reduction in prudence resulted in a significant
reduction in the funding deficit from that disclosed at the earlier valuation.

We helped out our client negotiate with the trustees to use more realistic return assumptions in the recovery plan, than were adopted in the valuation of the liabilities and this reduced the required extension to the recovery period. We helped our client put in place mitigation for the trustees agreeing to a reduction in recovery plan contributions. A profit-related element of the recovery plan was agreed, along with guarantees regarding the use of funds intended to support growth of the company.

Throughout the process we assisted our client in its detailed negotiations with the trustees to achieve the desired outcome.

The outcome

The sponsor released additional funds to enable it to pursue its growth plans, whilst maintaining its commitment to support the scheme at a reasonable cost.

The trustees were able to support an extended recovery plan on the basis of the likelihood of a stronger sponsor, with safeguards.

The potential upside of additional contributions could help them achieve their funding objective within the original timescale.


Insight Research

Our research reports are aimed at Pension Trustees and HR Directors, covering topics such as pensions, health, flexible benefits, engagement and wellness. They are free to download!

Find out more

Back to case studies

A selection of clients we've worked with and the benefits they've gained. 

Learn more

Get all our latest research and insights

Receive key regulatory research, opinion, guides and insight straight into your inbox.

Sign up now

Awards and accreditations